Most helpful client reviews

157 of 164 persons found the following review helpful.
Pretty Awesome Ice Cream Maker… **PRETTY** Awesome…
By Mike Zmuda
The Whynter Sno is a to a finish degree contained 2 liter ice cream machine. It will both churn and freeze a mix to create:

- Frozen Custard
- Ice Cream
- Ice Milk
- Gelato
- Sorbets
- and even icy beverages (think Margaritas and the like.)

========
The Pros
========

It Works!
^^^^^^^^^
(Yes, this is a big deal. How would you like it if you plunked down $200 only to find your ice cream mix comes out soup or filled with chunky ice cubes?) This machine unquestionably gets the occupation done; It makes ice cream.

It is astoundingly quiet.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
While you wouldn’t want to use it in a library, this machine is actually gorgeous quiet. Most of us who don’t have any experience with an Ice Cream Machine may only relate to the beasts they have at the local Ice-Creameries (You know the ones: Buy One, Get One Free on sure days…) These industrial behemoths are LOUD. This machine (not being an industrial behemoth) is not loud. It **IS** louder than my refrigerator (barely,) but not rather as deafening as my washing machine. It’s NO WHERE NEAR AS LOUD as a Blender, Food Processor, or Stick Blender (if those are your only gauges of relevance.)

You may make your own concoctions.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Some local ice-creameries will make you a habit blend of ice cream. For example, if you want chocolate chips in a heap of strawberry ice cream, they’ll do that. (Probably not nationwide chains, but the local shop might.) But ask them to make anything crazier than that, and you’re probably out of luck. Rosewater ice cream? Sorry. Green Tea ice cream? You’re probably out of luck.

With this machine, you may make whatsoever flavors your heart desires, and that’s pretty cool. (Just don’t save me any Alligator Sherbet, ok?)

Ease of Use / Capacity.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
This thing is EASY to use. For example, to make a simple vanilla ice cream, take 2 cups of half-and-half and POUR IT DIRECTLY INTO THE MACHINE’S MIXING BUCKET. DO LIKEWISE WITH 1/2 CUP OF SUGAR. Add a tablespoon of vanilla, and run the machine. About 45 minutes later, you’ll have medium soft serve ice cream. NOTE that I do not say “Bring this mixture to a boil,” nor do I say “Mix it,” nor anything like that. In fact, when I tried this mix, I could even listen the churn running over the grains of sugar in the churning bowl. But, 45 minutes later, not one thing but super-fine ice cream.

The other plus side is this machine’s capacity. It’s nice to be capable to make a more spectacular amount of a mix if the mix is a bit more elaborate (ie: a custard, which may require the incorporation of eggs, and possible cooking of the eggs.) This way, you may make a more spectacular batch of mix, followed by a larger batch of ice cream.

========
The Cons
========

It’s NOT dishwasher safe!
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
While I won’t say “Cleanup is hard,” (there are in truth only 2 things to clean: the bowl and the beater,) you still can’t just toss them into the top rack of your dishwasher to get the occupation done. You’ll also need to wipe off the top plastic cover with a sponge, dishrag, etc… because it’s permanently attached to the motor (which doesn’t lend itself to easy cleaning.) The same thing holds true if your mix overflows the bowl and gets into the machine itself. (Don’t worry, it’s easy to clean, but again, you can’t put the whole machine into your dishwasher [it's electrical, y'know,] so you’ll have to clean it with a sponge or dishrag…) In other words, it would have been nicer if the freezing bowl (into which the mixing bowl sits,) the mixing bowl, the churn, and the plastic cover all been removable and dishwasher safe. They’re not, but, to Whynter’s credit, they are pretty easy to clean.

The label came off
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Petty? Yes. But it’s an indicator as to the design of the machine. The label is a stiff label affixed to the rounded “tub” area of the machine. Had the machine been designed with a flat areat onto which the logo could be affixed, the label would still be there. (Mind you, this is “straight out of the box.”

Little or No Documentation
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
The documentation isn’t bad (for what there is of it, but there aren’t any recipes that come along with it. Also, there’s no indicator as to the Maximum Fill Level of the Churn bucket. Overfill it, and you’ve got an ice cream that won’t set properly, or have sufficient air mixed into it; or worse: ice cream base spilling into the freezing chamber. NOTE: You **CAN** go onto the web site and download a heap of recipes, but it would have been GREAT if they would have expended the extra $.38 and printed out a good deal of copies of at least a simple vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry mix recipe and thrown it into the box.

“Add-Ins” chute too small
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Do you like “Add-Ins” (ie: gelatin-based fruit-flavored candy animals and the like) in your ice cream? Well, you’ll need to stop the machine, open the top, add the Add-Ins, then restart the churn (which, ideally, you’d wait 6 minutes for, since the compressor doesn’t like to get started and stop without a 6 minute breather.) The current model has a chute big sufficient for sprinkles and MAYBE very little cookie crumbs, but not chocolate chips. Again, not the worst thing in the world, but… hey! You know.

It may be slow
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
This machine COULD conceivably turn out a batch of ice cream in 30 minutes, but that’s only if the mix is almost frozen to begin with (<38 degrees.) If you just cooked up a custard and it's still 170 degrees, it may well take this machine a few hours to turn your hot ice cream soup into ice cream. Having said that, even a 2 liter batch of cold mix won't be ice cream in anything less than 45 minutes to an hour.

=============
Other “Stuff”
=============

If you’ve never had an ice cream machine before, this machine is beauteous good. (Ok; it’s gorgeous GREAT.) But there are a few things you need to realize BEFORE buying ANY ice cream machine:

1 – NO ice cream machine will ever make ice cream for you that is rocket hard. The best you may ask for is the consistency of a firm soft serve, or a pint of super-premium that’s been left out on the counter for too long. Any good ice cream maker will tell you that once you’ve made your batch, put it in a container, then throw THAT in the freezer for a little while to get hard (and let the flavors mature.) Of course, if you like soft serve, you’re in good shape.

2 – DON’T suppose to buy this machine and make ice cream for the whole neighborhood. You won’t, for example, be capable to host the desserts table at your next block party equipped with only this machine and a heap of raw materials. At best, this machine could crank out regarding 8 servings of ice cream (with a very cold mix) in an hour, which won’t satisfy the needs of a heap of 50 ravenous neighborhood kids. If you NEED to supply your neighborhood with ice cream, you have 2 decent options:

A – Buy this machine, make the batches a day or so in advance, and let the ice cream harden (and mature) in the freezer ’till the huge day.
B – Forego this machine, and make “Nitrogen Ice Cream” (The Nitrogen, Dewar rental, and all ingredients will cost LESS than the price of this machine. The only caveat is that you HAVE TO KNOW WHAT YOU ARE DOING! Nitrogen makes people unhappy, exceptionally as their skin, tendons and muscles flake off revealing only bone after they suffer a nasty liquid Nitrogen burn [ok; not really, but still - it's nasty, painful stuff if you don't treat it right.]) Google “Nitrogen Ice Cream” for recipes, caveats, sources, and ideas. ADDED BONUS: Nitrogen Ice Cream puts on a cool show!

3 – You can’t adjust the air mix in this machine. Ask a severe ice cream maker, and she / he will tell you “it’s all in regards to the mix.” Even the Food and Drug Administration say that “Ice Creams” are classified by the amount of air (or “Overrun”) in the mix. More air = “fewer calories,” but likewise a less satisfying ice cream. “Super Premium” ice creams have less air. (But don’t worry: This machine is more geared towards “Super Premium” more than “really light and fluffy.”

4 – DON’T suppose this machine to save you money. (Yup – You heard right.) Sure, the price of 4 servings of super premium ice cream may be $3, but the cost of half-and-half, sugar, and flavorings (among other things) plus electricity to run the machine would likely put you in that same $3 range. (Ok, let’s face it: Ice cream isn’t a high-priced commodity.) The only good reason to get this machine is:

A – If you have special dietary needs
B – You’re REALLY into fresh cooking
C – You want to impress an person [ie: the kids, the neighbors, the in-laws, a date, etc...]

So there you have it. My review of the Whynter Sno Ice Cream Machine. If you’re an ice-cream maker newbie who has the cash, you will have to DEFINITELY consider this machine. If you’re a little low on cash, but still want to churn-your-own, try one of those units where you basi FREEZE the churn bucket then make the ice cream. If, on the other hand, you have a few extra thousand lying around… well… check out “Batch Freezers” rather of Ice Cream Makers. (They’ll make a LARGE batch of ice cream in 8 minutes, rather of 60, but they’re also MUCH noisier [and costlier.])

Hope this helps!

- Mike Z.

57 of 60 humans found the following review helpful.
Tentatively pleased
By Colin Purrington
I was close to buying the Lello equivalent (made by the same company), but decisive to undertake the Whynter. It’s much cheaper, and seems to have very similar specifications. I’ve applied it twice and I’ve been very pleased with results. I’m not in peculiar impressed by the engineering, and hence may only give it 3 stars currently. My main displeasure is that the lid cannot be washed, and the items that _can_ be washed will have to all be hand washed. I think that’s just lame. Unit is somewhat quiet. I’ll update this review in a few months. I’ve uploaded 10 photographs, too, and added a outstanding deal of notes to each that might help you determine whether this machine is a good choice for you.

35 of 36 persons found the following review helpful.
Also Makes the Lello Gelato Pro 4090
By Mother Goose
Look at the reviews of the Lello Gelato Pro 4090, Whynter makes them for Lello beneath a private label. Its a great Machine.

See all 25 client reviews…